Lowest Cost PHD/DBA

Discussion in 'Business and MBA degrees' started by matt, Aug 29, 2007.

  1. Johann766

    Johann766 Member

    Curacao allows co called TNE institutions to operate on their Island. I'm not sure if being a TNE institution, like global humanistic is, has got anything to do with state accreditation.

    Rich Douglas likes this.
  2. Rich Douglas

    Rich Douglas Well-Known Member

    Curacao comes under the Dutch authority, and that this thing is not recognized as a university by it. Yet the University of Curacao IS accredited. Hard to see how any of this sheds legitimacy on GHU.
  3. Johann

    Johann Well-Known Member

    "TNE institutions can establish themselves freely, however Universities should be accredited by an accrediting body which is approved by the Government of Curaçao."
    From http://tnecuracao.gobiernu.cw/institutions/

    Does this help? From the Government site, it appears that TNE universities do not pick up any kind of accreditation or equivalent from TNE status. They must be accredited by an accrediting body approved by the Government of Curaçao.
    Last edited: May 25, 2020
  4. Johann

    Johann Well-Known Member

    Well, I see Global Humanistic has the ubiquitous ASIC accreditation. Maybe Curaçao thinks that's sufficient? I'll stop right there...
  5. Johann

    Johann Well-Known Member

    I haven't read it, of course, but I'm thinking the Charter confers permission to operate and has nothing to do with accreditation. Just sayin' maybe it's not like a British Charter, which allows the university to establish itself and also makes it able to confer approved degrees. There are charters and charters, I guess, depending which country issues 'em.
  6. Johann

    Johann Well-Known Member

    They're certainly ambitious. They say they have partnerships with UC Riverside and Harvard B-school. Programs whereby you get a cert (Harvard) or PG Cert (UC Riverside) plus your GHU degree.

    However, it's never a good sign when you have to pore through much verbiage and detail in a search for legitimate accreditation or approval. It should be right there in the open. . I haven't found definitive proof of anything. The certs are top-notch - almost irresistible; the degree situation is murky - at least to my old eyes. Perhaps there's something I overlooked. Wouldn't be the first time...
  7. Rich Douglas

    Rich Douglas Well-Known Member

    Not to be cynical or anything (never, NEVER!), but I'd check to see if UC Riverside or Harvard cite these respective "partnerships." Just sayin'.....
    RoscoeB likes this.
  8. Johann766

    Johann766 Member

  9. Rich Douglas

    Rich Douglas Well-Known Member

    In a way, you did.
  10. Rich Douglas

    Rich Douglas Well-Known Member

    I was on the EBS website at Heriot-Watt last night. I don't keep up with such things, so I was really interested to see a few developments. (Apologies to those who already know this.) The doctorate is no longer course-based. You take three research-skills courses, then anything else your advisor recommends (likely nothing if you're researching in an area in which you have subject matter expertise.) Then you write your thesis, earning either the PhD or the DBA. The process is the same.

    So what's the difference? First, the PhD is considered a scholarly contribution to the field, while the DBA contributes to practice. (The exact distinction I've been making on this board for years.) The PhD is designed for entry into academia and the DBA for advancing one's business career. Sound familiar? There are no other distinctions between the two awards.

    Second, they've eliminated the coursework for the DBA, which used to be a "taught" degree.

    Second, because it is a "big book" approach, your thesis will be quite large (like 100K words). This is true for either degree.

    Third, their expectation for the structure is quite traditional: a literature review resulting in a particular problem to research, research and writing, then defense. It does not appear one must go to Scotland to defend.

    Fourth, the award (the PhD or the DBA) from EBS is available by distance learning only. This is either good or bad, depending on your point of view.

    Finally, the cost. It's really inexpensive. The current estimate for US students is just under US$24K and the degree can be done in 3 years. It must be done in 5, with a US$6.5K tuition charge for each year.

    They have a small number of graduates (around 50) and a small number of current candidates. In other words, it's a serious undertaking. I'm always dismayed at the amount of loose talk about doctoral degrees on this board, when very few people have actually earned one while posting here. Here's one of the most available and inexpensive doctorates in business around, yet it has just a handful of graduates and another handful of students. This stuff is hard.

    Which brings me to another criticism of some of the talk on this board: the "my school is better than your school" nonsense. Doing a college degree is hard. I don't care if you do it at an Ivy League school or some DEAC-accredited school no one's ever heard of. It's hard. That goes for getting the doctorate, too. While the nattering on this topic by those who have not earned a doctorate is annoying, I'm really disappointed in people who HAVE done it and insist on this behavior. For example, getting a doctorate from an unknown RA school is no reason to lord over people doing one (or have done one) at a DEAC-accredited school, just as getting one from a top-ranked university is no reason to lord over that person with the PhD from that unknown RA school. (Long-time readers know exactly who and what I'm talking about.) It is pointless, junior high locker room jockeying.

    When I graduated from Union, a certain troll (who I know) downloaded by dissertation from ProQuest, then passed around the good-for-72-hours code. It was downloaded a total of 66 times in those three days. (I had to put a stop to it with ProQuest.) Because I'm the target of a lot of anonymous trolls--my dissertation was savaged. Wrongly, of course. Inaccurately, naturally. It was crazy and stupid. The funny thing is, no one with an actual doctorate ever said anything like that. The one critic at the time with a PhD (from U of South Carolina, IIRC) shrugged and said it looked okay to him. (High praise coming from this really harsh dude.) I look back on it now and see several things I would do differently. But that's to be expected after nearly 20 years of reflection.

    The point? Two very simple ones. If you haven't done a doctorate, shut up about others' doctorates--their school, their research, etc. You don't know what you're talking about. Instead, listen and ask questions. You might (or might not) learn something valuable in your quest for yours. And if you've done a doctorate, shut up about others who have done theirs at legitimate, recognized schools. The distinctions you make do not really make much of a difference. Yes, we can have the RA/NA argument, but when you criticize individuals for pursuing their goals like that, it only lowers you.
  11. GregWatts

    GregWatts Active Member

    I would just second Rich's response; if I were to consider a DBA or PhD in business (which I am not) and had any cost restrictions, Heriot-Watt would ABSOLUTELY (emphasis intended) be on my shortlist, if not at the top.
  12. JoshD

    JoshD Well-Known Member

    I have not earned a doctoral degree but I always have high praise for those that have regardless of the mode of instruction or the university they attend. My MBA was a lot of work and I did not have to worry about writing and defending anything. I believe at the doctoral level, the university is less important than at the masters level, correct me if I am wrong.
  13. SteveFoerster

    SteveFoerster Resident Gadfly Staff Member

    It can be much more important or much less. It all depends on what one's goals are.
    Rich Douglas, RoscoeB and JoshD like this.
  14. JoshD

    JoshD Well-Known Member

    Thanks Steve! I am not super familiar with doctoral studies and the nuances. I guess if one wanted to move into academia it would make a difference. What other goals help decide this?

Share This Page