MIGS: The Sequel

Discussion in 'The Monterrey Institute for Graduate Studies' started by Guest, Aug 5, 2001.

Loading...
  1. Guest

    Guest Guest

    For over a year it seemed that MIGS was one of the hottest topic around, at least on AED and DegreeInfo. Even to the point of MIGS getting its own forum on DegreeInfo.

    There is usually a sequel to every story, so what is it here? What has become of MIGS?

    Russell
     
  2. tcnixon

    tcnixon New Member

    Messages:
    1,592
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    California, USA
    Like many senior citizens, MIGS has retired to scenic property in lovely Monterrey, Mexico, where it sips Pina Coladas and bets on the Jai Alai games.

    Tom Nixon

    P.S. In theory, MIGS (now re-named) is operating in Mexico. In practice, it appears that it is still operating from Florida and, according to others here, doing so illegally.


    tn
     
  3. Bill Highsmith

    Bill Highsmith New Member

    Messages:
    650
    Likes Received:
    0
    Considering the frequency of MIGS posts, lately, perhaps it can be brought back into the General Discussion board.
     
  4. irat

    irat New Member

    Messages:
    442
    Likes Received:
    0
    Occupation:
    education consultant
    Location:
    Grand Isle, VT USA
    I think the essential questions remain the same. If Centro del Estudios Universiarios meets GAAP, then doesn't the Center for University Graduate Studies, also meet GAAP. One would assume that CUGS will now appear on a CEU organization chart. When someone calls CEU, most workers ought to know that CUGS is an internal entity.
    The issues of whether CUGS has good faculty is an issue of quality. The issue of whether CUGS has administrators who make it sound like a degree mill is again, an issue of quality. The issue of whether one would be ill advised to virtually go there, is again issue of quality.
    Can anyone answer the central questions for the centro. Does CEU meet GAAP? and is CUGS really a unit of CEU?
    irat
     
  5. Rich Douglas

    Rich Douglas Active Member

    Messages:
    11,356
    Likes Received:
    0
    The CEU meets GAAP. It is listed in both the IHU and the World Education Series by PIER (on behalf of AACRAO). Schools listed in either of these tend to be acceptable to admissions officers.

    MIGS is most certainly not an integral part of the CEU. It is a separate entitity, with separate ownership. The owners have a contract with the CEU to offer programs leading to CEU degrees.

    Assuming you really can get a CEU degree via MIGS, then the product is the same. But the process is certainly not, and is not well thought of (as evidenced by many people's posts, not just mine). But do you end up with a degree from the CEU, or just one signed by Arias and Forman? MIGS will tell you the former. I hope they're right.

    Rich Douglas
     
  6. tcnixon

    tcnixon New Member

    Messages:
    1,592
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    California, USA
    Isn't that the question, though? If it is a degree signed by Arias and Forman, what is it worth?

    It will be interesting to see what happens when they finally have their first graduate. Anyone know a timetable for when that august event should happen?


    Tom Nixon
     
  7. Chip

    Chip Administrator

    Messages:
    2,357
    Likes Received:
    10
    Probably about as much as a degree from any other unaccredited school that has claimed to move from one country to another, while reportedly still illegally maintaining its operations in the original country, changed it's webpage 500 times, always immediately after someone here pointed something out, and advertised its services on a website featuring "get rich quick" schemes and a link to term papers for sale.

    In other words, not much.

    I find it particularly interesting that when someone who was fluent in Spanish called the CEU several months ago, his report was that no one at CEU seemed to know anything at all about the MIGS program (and this guy spoke to a bunch of folks there in different departments). When someone was finally located who did know something about it, all he said was that CEU had nothing at all to do with the MIGS program, that it was simply a contractual arrangement. Of course, they now have letters and pretty pictures and a mailbox rental address that says otherwise, but I suspect that we're talking window dressing, not substantive change.

    And the "rental accreditation" scam is what I suspected all along.
     
  8. Rich Douglas

    Rich Douglas Active Member

    Messages:
    11,356
    Likes Received:
    0
    But it didn't have to be this way. In my second (of two) breakfast meetings with Arias, it was clear to him that MIGS represented an opportunity to do several things. First, he wanted to introduce greater across-the-border networking for the CEU and institutions in the U.S. He certainly is the guy for that. Second, he saw an opportunity to implement education technologies into the graduate program. This really wasn't happening, however; MIGS remains very low-tech. Third, he saw an opportunity to develop programs with MIGS that could be used to upgrade the qualifications of faculty members at the CEU and other Mexican universities. I saw limited benefit for CEU faculty. (Too many getting their degrees at their own school wasn't a good idea, I thought.) But building cooperative programs at other schools could have been productive. (This is/was in the works, BTW.)

    Unfortunately, Arias doesn't run things, Forman does. Arias makes no decisions commensurate with his title and position. He is head of state to Forman's head of government. Sadly, Forman is incapable of running such a program, and the only managerial support the program receives is in the form of an illegal Florida operation, a mail-forwarding service in Mexico, horrendous promotion links to dubious web sites, a home site that tells lies, etc. But take all that away (or, better yet, fix it), and you still have problems. You've got a very suspect Assessment of Prior Learning process, no administrative functions to support students and their learning, and no learning resources (notice that their web site is all about promotion, but there is nothing for students to use). Finally, their academic processes are superficial at best. I only know about two students in detail, me and one other person, both admitted "ABD." They admitted me on the basis of my Union work. Fine, but they did it before they saw and evaluated my prior doctoral work. Once they asked me to come on board to assist them, I was an ABD. I still provided them all the documentation, and included it all in my learning contract, but it was clear that it just didn't matter. In fact, Forman told me I had too much in my learning contract and to cut it down.

    The other student I'm familiar with was admitted ABD despite not having done doctoral work at an accredited school. This person did have two doctorates from unaccredited schools connected to one of the owners of MIGS. I don't know if those were used as the basis for this person's ABD status.

    Lame, really lame.

    Rich Douglas
     
  9. Bill Huffman

    Bill Huffman New Member

    Messages:
    4,394
    Likes Received:
    0
    Occupation:
    Software Engineer
    Location:
    San Diego, CA, USA
    For a DL school an expensive task is ensuring that the students have learned the necessary subjects. IMHO, one of the biggest differences between a degree mill and a real school is that the degree mill trims back on this expensive aspect of running a real school.
     
  10. Rich Douglas

    Rich Douglas Active Member

    Messages:
    11,356
    Likes Received:
    0
    Yeah. The only one incurring any expense was me. I paid them a hundred bucks for the APL.

    Rich Douglas
     
  11. Timmy Ade

    Timmy Ade New Member

    Messages:
    124
    Likes Received:
    0
    Occupation:
    INSTRUCTOR
    Location:
    Atlanta GA ,USA.
    Chip and Rich,
    as someone already pointed out,all said in your respective postings still rest on the issue of quality, and not illegality. My questions to you fellows now are: (1) if and when we witness a Migs's degree issued and signed by CEU officials as opposed to Arias and Forman, Will you Guys then go easy on what has now turned to"ANTI MIGS CRUSADE" ? And (2) better yet will you now offer some respect/appology (however pettite) to Migs considering your previous brutal attcks on them ?
    Thanks,

    Timmy Ade who is not a Migs scholar.
     
  12. Bill Huffman

    Bill Huffman New Member

    Messages:
    4,394
    Likes Received:
    0
    Occupation:
    Software Engineer
    Location:
    San Diego, CA, USA
    I'm not Chip or Rich, but I must say that I have not said anything that I feel I need to apologize for. MIGS is apparently operating illegally but let's even ignore that. I do not hold to the notion that an institution must be operating illegally before I can call it a degree mill. From my view, MIGS has behaved so like a degree mill I feel it's reasonable to label them such. If it walks and quakes like a duck then I'm calling it a duck.

    To me MIGS looks like a degree mill that possibly has a thicker veneer of legitimacy than some other degree mills. (If they're accepting candidates as ABD for PhD's without any apparent evaluation what else can you call them?)

    I don't think that Chip or Rich have even called MIGS a degree mill. What have they said that is untrue? What has been said about MIGS that has turned out to even be inaccurate? What has been said that an apology is in order? Especially just because some student finally gets a diploma from el MIGS with CEU printed at the top, what kind of apology would you then envision? All that has been said regarding that is that it is currently unclear that CEU will be at the top of the diploma. The Oregon ODA hasn't been able to verify this. Are we all supposed to just shrug and accept it on faith? (I guess I could if I really wanted to but I sure can't blame Rich for not wanting to.)
     
  13. Peter French

    Peter French member

    Messages:
    586
    Likes Received:
    0
    Occupation:
    Consultant to the Education & Training Industries.
    Location:
    Melbourne, Australia
    You used the word 'lame' Rich ....!

    My 2 'doctorates' as you call them are of equivelent value to John Bear's Harvard whatever it is, are not used and I have made that abundantly clear to everyone who WANTS to understand that, which obviously excludes you, but that isn't exactly a change of attitude is it?

    I have (1) a Masters degree that quite considerably exceeds the requirements for a US MEd, which incidentally in my second and 'lesser' Masters; (2) I have done considerable and established POST MEd study and research which has been established by my Univerisity here, and has been part of professional and Government/Regulatory submissions here in the area of Higher Education Administration. They incidentally want me to do my PhD with them, but accept my choice and have offered me seminar and doctoral colloquia facilities, as well as mentorship, supervision, library and research support. This is after having looked at CEU who incidentally approved my APL. My APL was processed on directly substantiated evidence from my official transcript - NOT a photocopy, and backed by the course outlines in the University Calendar, and other independendently provided information.

    Rich, leave you hangups out of this, and try and regain some objectivity. Most of us are tired of your 'problems' so quitely back off the topic. It will save your face being redder than it will need to be a little later when you have reason to realise that your decision may not have been the wisest, or at least was made on some pretty serious misconceptions.

    It just may give another dimension to your favourite word 'Lame' :)

    Take a tip from a friend a little older, a little wiser, and little more intelligent if I may be as bold as to say that.

    I have enough work to do completing my PhD and now being called in to overhaul another HE college nationally that has problems at the top and with quality delivery and assessment - so don't expect me to get into a converstaion, argument, pissing contest or whatever you are looking for.

    Anyone who wants to talk to me about CEU can do so at [email protected]

    Peter French
    M.Acc. M.Ed. B.Ed
    Univerisity of New England, Australia
     
  14. Rich Douglas

    Rich Douglas Active Member

    Messages:
    11,356
    Likes Received:
    0
    You're welcome.

    Seriously, I really appreciate your concern for the well-being of MIGS and how I or others might damage it. But not to worry. No greater wounds could be brought than those that have already been self-inflicted.

    Rich Douglas
     
  15. Peter French

    Peter French member

    Messages:
    586
    Likes Received:
    0
    Occupation:
    Consultant to the Education & Training Industries.
    Location:
    Melbourne, Australia
    You are really a laugh a minute as well as being the highest contributor to the group ...truly reminds me of someone ... but your logic is really funny, should help with your PhD.

    The logic comes from early discharge from the defence forces, or spending too long with the screws? Never mind Rich one day you'll learn to live with those frustrations that continually beset you.

    Linking the 'other student' and ' the owner of MIGS', and the 'owner of MIGS' and those 'universities' in like deducting that as you and your wife both use the can, you must be transgender :))

    Rich, dear Rich, at least you keep the NG alive - by design or defualt? ...really it doesn't matter I suppose ...

    Peter
     
  16. Rich Douglas

    Rich Douglas Active Member

    Messages:
    11,356
    Likes Received:
    0

    Thank you for that scintillating violation of the TOS.

    Rich Douglas
     
  17. Bruce

    Bruce Moderator

    Messages:
    9,607
    Likes Received:
    12
    Occupation:
    Police Officer/Adjunct College Instructor
    Location:
    Boston, MA
    What is it about MIGS discussions that brings out the nasty side of many?

    People...it really isn't necessary to resort to personal attacks or rudeness. IMO, in most cases it turns people off & undermines your argument.

    Bruce
     
  18. Timmy Ade

    Timmy Ade New Member

    Messages:
    124
    Likes Received:
    0
    Occupation:
    INSTRUCTOR
    Location:
    Atlanta GA ,USA.
    Bill,
    The point that I am making is simply this:
    MIGS is probably guilty of a lot of stuff, Certainly Degree Milling is not one of them.
    And Rich, I sincerely think that you are doing a graet job in your contributions to the issue of DL in today's America.But as far as I am concerened,There is a case of over-kill on the MIGS issue,and it's begining to sound and look like "LET'S GET MIGS.
    Timmy who was scared away from Migs by
    Chip,Rich and Bill :.))
     
  19. Rich Douglas

    Rich Douglas Active Member

    Messages:
    11,356
    Likes Received:
    0
    I note through a search of the alt.education.distance newsgroup a post from the above noting he'd accepted a role in preparing that ng's "official" FAQ. In that FAQ he is listed as "Peter J. French, Ph.D." No explanation, no "For Novelty Purposes Only" warning label, no Caveat Emptor in the watermark. No mention of his fake Ed.D. Just "Peter J. French, Ph.D." And MIGS makes three.

    Dr. French fails to realize this isn't about him--or me. It is about MIGS.

    Rich Douglas
     
  20. irat

    irat New Member

    Messages:
    442
    Likes Received:
    0
    Occupation:
    education consultant
    Location:
    Grand Isle, VT USA
    The CUGS/MIGS discussion certainly does seem to get heated and personal. I hope this question brings things back to facts and logic.
    The closest comparison I can think of for CUGS/MIGS and CEU is to GST and Potch. What things has Potch. done to promote/validate its connection to GST? Don't people at Potch. recognize their connection to GST?
    If the relationship between CEU and CUGS/MIGS is real, CEU must promote/validate it in some manner.
    It would seem that the problem is, CEU is too quiet on the connection (if there is one). This is logically odd for a legitimate school breaking a trail into a new international frontier. Why are they passing up free publicity? Are they poor marketers? Or are there other reasons?
    I think these are the hard questions to answer, but they seem like the ones that get at the heart of the controversy. irat
     

Share This Page