The Canadian Institute of English

Discussion in 'Accreditation Discussions (RA, DETC, state approva' started by LVerkade, Dec 15, 2005.

Loading...
  1. LVerkade

    LVerkade New Member

    This "Institute" has a mailing address at P.O. Box 86, Georgetown, Ontario, Canada. They claim affiliation with the Saint Petersburg State University and the Universidad Autonoma del Estado de Mexico (Autonomous University of the State of Mexico) - the universities grant the degrees and transcripts. It appears that all programs and courses are offered via distance only.

    The Institute website is at (link removed by moderator) and lists Dr. Harry Cotton as the Director, Ms Beth Cotton as the University Accounting Department, Mr. Lloyd Jenkins as the University Liaison Registrar (his address is in Torremolinas, Malaga, Spain), Dean Jenkins and Robin Jenkins as Tutors.

    My understanding is that none of the institutions mentioned above is licensed or recognized by the Ontario Ministry of Education, nor are they authorized to teach or offer degrees in Ontario.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 27, 2011
  2. sentinel

    sentinel New Member

    If a school located in Ontario is NOT recognized by the Ontario Ministry of Education, then the school is NOT legitimate. Even private vocational/technical schools in the Province of Ontario must be registered with and approved by the Ontario Ministry of Education.
     
  3. George Brown

    George Brown Active Member

    It used to be in partnership with Bircham International University for many years. Nuff said.

    Cheers,

    George
     
  4. davidhume

    davidhume New Member

    Yes, and have tried all sorts of other unaccredited linkages from time to time...

    Stay away!
     
  5. aprilgraef

    aprilgraef New Member

    I've taken the TESOL course offered at the Canadian Institute of English and have benefited greatly from the instruction. I've learned about various teaching methods that have proved to be effective in teaching a foreign language. The course is designed to prepare TESOL instructors who have the goal of mainly teaching outside of the US and Canada. I think this is a wonderful program and would recommend it to anyone desirous of teaching TESOL outside of the US and Canada.
     
  6. Kizmet

    Kizmet Moderator

    Yet another in an apparently neverending series of people registering with the site for the sole purpose of digging up an ancient thread for the purpose of promoting another un-wonderful entity. This pattern has become so familiar that it is clearly backfiring. Does april really think that she's convincing anyone that this is a legitimate university? I'm suggesting that she's doing the exact opposite. She's convincing everyone that this is a scam school just by dredging up this old thread and making an unconvincing endorsement.
    :lame:
     
  7. SteveFoerster

    SteveFoerster Resident Gadfly Staff Member

    This thread has a link to that institution on it. IIRC, by refreshing it with her comment, it makes it weigh more for search engine optimization. So in other words, it doesn't matter that the thread itself is unconvincing, since people searching on Google will be more likely to find them because of this thread even without ever seeing it.

    -=Steve=-
     
  8. Kizmet

    Kizmet Moderator

    Thanks Steve, I had forgotten that step. The link has been removed.
     
  9. Maniac Craniac

    Maniac Craniac Moderator Staff Member

    I am very familiar with this institution. The CIE's live tesl/slam courses are 100% legitimate, but they have a long history of partnerships with diploma mills that accept their courses as "transfer." Mr.Cotton himself boasts multiple graduate degrees from schools with either fake or unrecognized accreditation. It is sad, confusing situation, really. If it wasn't for that, it would be a fantastic program.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 27, 2011
  10. Maniac Craniac

    Maniac Craniac Moderator Staff Member

    Allow me to add that since they are not a college, they, themselves don't need any form of accreditation. Those who finish the week-long program get a certificate of completion.

    There is no recognized body in either us or Canada that evaluates/approves tesl certificates. Their value depends upon the reputation of the school that awards them.
     
  11. David Chappell

    David Chappell New Member

    The original poster has created confusion by posting evidence that the CIE is not a real university. This is confusing because it is not a university of any kind. It is a small business which conducts five-day face-to-face seminars for teachers of English as a second language.

    I stumbled on this thread while searching for Harry Cotton's e-mail address. I have registered to post a reply because I resent the aspersions cast on Harry Cotton's character and his course. Before anyone says that I am trying to boost the CIE's page rank, I would like to point out that the link was removed long ago after April's posting was incorrectly identified as spam.

    At the end of the seminar the students get a certificate which states that they have completed a 40-hour course in teaching English as a second language (TESOL). I gather the course is primarily meant for young people who want to live abroad for a few years and need a way to support themselves. Teaching English is a good way to do this. I have a friend who took Harry Cotton's course and supported himself as an English tutor for several years in Estonia.

    I was sent to a seminar conducted by Harry Cotton by an organization for which I do volunteer work. It was not the usual dull continuing education program. It turned out to be an intense workshop conducted by a very enthusiastic and knowledable instructor. He really does teach important techniques which are not yet widely used. I have since used many of them with great success and would never go back to the old ways.

    We were all there for a special continuing education version of the program, but someone asked about the certificate version and prospects for getting work with it. He said that it depended on the country where you wanted to work. For some countries a college degree is required. That was when he mentioned the distance learning program at the Caribean medical school. He said the degree is not at all prestigious, but good enough to fulfill the legal requirements in several countries. This was not something he was recommending to his students in general.

    In short, Harry Cotton teaches a good seminar which is well worth the $600 he charges. April's endorsement isn't fake even if it sounds suspiciously generic. That is what all his students really think of the program. Word-of-mouth keeps it alive, not fake reviews.
     
  12. Maniac Craniac

    Maniac Craniac Moderator Staff Member

    @David Chappell, and whomever it may concern.

    I am very familiar with Harry Cotton's program, although I have not attended, myself.

    Accreditation is a non-issue. There is no accreditation for TESOL/SLAM instruction in Canada, as I've mentioned before. I've known dozens of people who have taken the Harry Cotton course, and they all absolutely rave about it, so I'm inclined to believe that there is genuine value to it.

    I know the volunteer (religious) organization to which you are referring. As a language professional, myself, I can vouch for the high quality of the translations they produce. However, I also know well their tendency to straddle the legal and ethical lines under the guise that they don't need approval from Satan's world to do what they do. That's just one of many reasons why members are have been so succeptible to diploma mill trickery.

    Here are the actual issues when it comes to Harry Cotton and his program. One is that he refers to himself as a Doctor, touting multiple Ph.Ds from highly irreputable schools. Everyone I know who has completed his program refers to him as "Dr. Cotton". That leads me to believe that he introduces himself as such, which is highly unethical given the amount of deference his students afford him as an instructor.

    Secondly, he has had several partnerships with "schools" that you, yourself, recognize as being irreputable. There is no excuse for that. To get a legitimate, respectable degree is no small task for anyone wanting to go about it the honest way. Even for those who pursue education vis non-traditional means. It is frustrating to see others shamelessly undermine that effort in order to receive fake credentials that they try to pass off as equivalently legit.

    Lastly, there is one particular business practice of Mr and Mrs Cotton that gets deeply under my skin. Completing their course yields you a TESOL certificate, which is just fine in and of itself. Then, if you want to, you can pay an extra fee (last I checked it was $40-$50) to have them print out a second certificate for you in what they call Second Language Acquisition Method. This is just a credential-inflating money grab. For a few bucks, you csn snag a second certificate with no additional effort. BUT WAIT THERE'S MORE!!!! You aren't just limited to one. You can get a "SLAM" certificate in any of a number of languages just by checking a box on the website and paying an extra fee. There is absolutely no verification of competency in the language, at all. There is absolutely no instruction offered by the CIE in any of those languages. Pay them $500 and BAM!!! You get 10 extra certificates, implying that you received training in teaching 10 different languages. It makes no difference if you know the language well or if you don't know a single word of it.

    Summary of the CIE: The language course itself is well-reviewed and I've even been tempted to try it. But I haven't, and I won't. Their business practices are not entirely on the up-and-up and are not consistent with the honest, good old family business image that Mr and Mrs Cotton are trying to present of themselves.
     
  13. LVerkade

    LVerkade New Member

    Really?

    1) How interesting that my post from 2005 is still generating comment
    2) how sad that much of that commentary is from people who feel the CIE needs to be defended
    3) how depressing that organizations such as this can continue to operate
    4) other threads on DegreeInfo are also concerned with this organization: for example - http://www.degreeinfo.com/accreditation-discussions-ra-detc-state-approval-unaccredited-schools/15134-canadian-institute-english-cie.html. If the link does not display or is deleted search for "Canadian Institute of English CIE"
     
  14. Johann

    Johann Well-Known Member

    Thanks twice, Maniac.

    (1) for teaching me what a TESOL / SLAM is. I thought it was something like a "poetry slam" and perhaps the object was to cram as much English instruction as possible into a 5 or 7 minute rhyming session. :smile:

    (2) for exposing Mr. Cotton's business practices. I don't care how good the instruction is - the business model, as described, sounds utterly unacceptable.

    Johann

    PS - BTW - I've heard that most places hiring English teachers for overseas work make sure applicants' degrees are "real." No?
     

Share This Page